Landlords fail to win rent rises ‘because of thin evidence’ – claim
Summary
An analysis of 336 rent tribunal decisions in England under the new market rent procedure suggests many landlords are not securing the full rent increases they seek because of weak paperwork and limited evidence. The study found that while most challenged rents still rose, tribunals frequently reduced the proposed increase, and in some cases set rents below the tenant’s existing level.
Why it matters
This is relevant to residential property surveyors because rent tribunal outcomes depend heavily on valuation evidence, comparable selection and procedural accuracy. It highlights the importance of robust market evidence and correct notice preparation when advising on rent reviews or disputed rental valuations.
Key points
- Most challenged rent increases were reduced by tribunals, with only 35% of landlords awarded the full amount sought.
- Procedural errors in notices caused some cases to fail before rent was considered, especially in London.
- Tribunals often discounted evidence that lacked key details or relied on weak comparables and asking rents.
- Some landlords asked for less than the market rent, which capped the tribunal award below assessed market level.
- Decisions can take months, and weak submissions may leave rent unchanged for a significant period.
This is an RPSA summary of a publicly available article. The full content remains with the original publisher.
